AN ARCHITECTURAL MATERIALS JOURNALFOUNDING EDITION EXTERIOR CLADDING
← Articles & Insights

OUR EDITORIAL APPROACH

Evidence first. Rankings second.

The directory starts with sourced product profiles. Rankings require a separate review. Unrated products are not inferior products, and a high score is not a substitute for project-specific suitability.

A visible scorecard

CriterionWeight
Performance evidence
Relevant test reports, assembly limitations and specification clarity.
30%
Durability & aging
Documented exposure, maintenance requirements and long-term field evidence.
25%
Design & detailing
Finish quality, format flexibility, fixing options and usable technical details.
10%
Manufacturing transparency
Named producer, factory locations and traceable product-specific origin.
10%
Value & support
Comparable scope of supply, warranty terms and project support.
10%
Environmental & material health
Product-specific environmental impacts, ingredient transparency and applicable declarations, with scope and validity checked.
5%
Lifetime ownership cost
Cleaning, maintenance, repair and replacement costs over a stated service period and project scope.
5%
Architectural impact
The wow factor: distinctive expression, depth, texture, light and creative possibilities demonstrated across completed projects.
5%

Each criterion is rated from 0 to 5 in half-point increments: 0, 0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 3.5, 4, 4.5 and 5. The weighted score is the sum of each rating divided by five, multiplied by its weight. Products rank from highest to lowest within their material category; equal scores share a rank.

Use 0 for a documented failure to meet the criterion, 1 for weak evidence or performance, 3 for adequate documented evidence, and 5 for exceptionally thorough evidence and performance against the stated criterion. Half points express an assessment between adjacent levels. Leave unreviewed criteria blank; missing information is not automatically a zero. Every scorecard needs a named reviewer and a written basis. This is an editorial framework, not a certified test standard.

Architectural impact · the wow factor

Assess the material’s contribution to distinctive, compelling architecture: surface character, depth, texture, light and creative range, supported by several completed projects. Quiet refinement can score as highly as bold expression. Consider the architect’s design, installation and photography separately from what the cladding itself contributes.

Who makes it?

Profiles distinguish a direct manufacturer, a brand with group-owned manufacturing, and a manufacturer with partner finishing. Outsourced or private-label production will be identified when supported by evidence. Lack of evidence is shown as unknown, never treated as proof of outsourcing.

Country filters use documented production sites. Multi-site products can appear under multiple countries; an order’s actual origin must be confirmed with its supplier. Factory location is not automatically raw-material origin or a legal country-of-origin determination.

Our seal and activity badges

The Seal of Approval records The Facade Guy’s explicit editorial endorsement within a stated scope. It reflects his professional judgment; it does not certify that every research or verification step is complete. Each approval record discloses its basis, known commercial relationship and outstanding documentation. Visits, interviews and verification findings are reported separately. Manufacturer Interviewed and Factory Visited record completed activities, not approval. A manufacturer can hold both badges without receiving the Seal of Approval. The seal is never granted automatically; it requires The Facade Guy’s separate editorial decision. Each approval identifies its authorizer, date and scope. Activity records identify missing dates or details explicitly. The November 14, 2026 approvals include named brands and currently listed FNW-represented lines, as authorized by The Facade Guy. These are disclosed editorial endorsements, not independent certifications. Advertising and sponsorship cannot influence product rankings or approval marks.

Read what our marks mean ↗

Commercial relationships

The Facade Guy, founder of The Cladding Review, is associated with Facades Northwest. Some featured brands have a commercial relationship with that business; known relationships are stated in their profiles. Relationships are disclosed beside relevant profiles. Manufacturer logos do not imply endorsement by the manufacturer.

THE MONTHLY CLADDING REVIEW

Good materials.
Fresh perspective.

New materials, project inspiration and practical cladding insights, once a month. From The Facade Guy.

Join our mailing list